PCB assembly technology comparison: SMT vs THT
PCB assembly technology involves soldering various electronic components (such as resistors, capacitors, and integrated circuits) onto a PCB according to design requirements, connecting them into a complete electronic product. This technology is an indispensable part of modern electronics, playing a decisive role in the performance and functionality of electronic devices.
Choosing the right assembly technique is crucial, as it directly impacts the final product’s performance, durability, and cost-effectiveness. Factors such as circuit complexity, component types, application requirements, and production volume all influence the selection of the most suitable assembly method. In this article, we will introduce two PCB assembly techniques: Surface Mount Technology (SMT) and Through-Hole Technology (THT), comparing their processes, advantages, disadvantages, and applications.
What is Surface Mount Technology?
Surface Mount Technology (SMT) is the latest method for mounting components onto circuit boards. It has replaced Through-Hole Technology due to certain advantages. SMT involves directly placing electronic components on the surface of the PCB.
This technique relies on automation, utilizing pick-and-place machines to position components onto the board. It is considered the second revolution in electronic assembly. SMT employs wave soldering and reflow soldering to secure components.
The advent of SMT has helped reduce manufacturing costs while maximizing PCB space usage. Developed in the 1960s and gaining popularity in the 1980s, this technology is ideal for high-end PCBs. SMT’s use has led to smaller components, and it also allows for component placement on both sides of the board.
In SMT, manufacturers install components without drilling holes. These components either have no leads or smaller ones. A precise amount of solder paste is applied to the board, and since SMT boards require fewer drill holes, they are more compact, allowing for better wiring.
What is Through-Hole Technology?
Through-Hole Technology (THT) involves the use of leads on components that are inserted into drilled holes on the PCB and soldered to pads on the opposite side. These leads may be inserted manually or by automated machines. The soldering process can be done by hand or through wave soldering, which is more suitable for large-scale production.
Components used in THT are typically larger than those used in SMT because they require leads to be inserted into holes. Common components in THT include resistors, capacitors, inductors, and integrated circuits.
Advantages of Surface Mount Technology
High-Density Assembly:
SMT enables high-density assembly of electronic components, as they are mounted directly on the PCB surface, minimizing the space between components. This allows electronic products to become more compact and lightweight. Typically, after adopting SMT, the size of electronic products can be reduced by 40-60%, and weight by 60-90%.
Efficient Automation:
SMT production lines are highly automated, allowing for high-speed, precise component placement, significantly improving production efficiency. This not only reduces labor costs but also minimizes human error, enhancing product quality.
Superior Electrical Performance:
With shorter or no leads on components, parasitic inductance and capacitance in circuits are reduced, improving electrical performance and minimizing signal attenuation and interference. This makes SMT particularly effective in high-frequency circuits and high-speed signal processing.
Cost Reduction:
The small size of SMT components saves PCB space and material costs. Additionally, automation reduces labor and time expenses, lowering overall production costs. It’s estimated that using SMT can reduce production costs by 30-50%.
Improved Reliability:
The shorter or leadless design of SMT components decreases the likelihood of issues caused by loose or corroded leads. Furthermore, the low defect rate of solder joints enhances overall product reliability.
Excellent High-Frequency Characteristics:
Due to the absence or shortness of leads, SMT naturally reduces distributed parameters in circuits, minimizing RF interference and facilitating the transmission and processing of high-frequency signals.
High Design Flexibility:
SMT offers greater flexibility in PCB design, allowing easy adjustments in component layout and wiring to accommodate various product requirements.
Disadvantages of Surface Mount Technology
Difficult to Repair:
SMT components are densely mounted on the PCB, making repairs relatively challenging when failures occur. In some cases, entire circuit boards may need to be replaced, increasing repair costs and time.
High Equipment Requirements:
SMT relies on high-precision automated equipment, which entails considerable costs for purchase and maintenance. This can pose financial challenges, especially for small and medium-sized manufacturers.
Temperature Sensitivity:
SMT components are highly sensitive to temperature during soldering. Excessive heat may damage the components, while insufficient heat could lead to weak soldering. Thus, precise control of temperature and timing is essential during the soldering process.
Static Sensitivity:
Many SMT components are extremely sensitive to static electricity, requiring strict anti-static measures during production. Without these precautions, static discharge could damage components or degrade their performance.
Difficult to Inspect:
The small size and dense arrangement of SMT components on the PCB make quality inspection more complex. High-precision testing equipment and specialized skills are needed, which increases both the difficulty and cost of inspections.
Complex Technology:
SMT involves knowledge and skills across various disciplines, including electronics, mechanics, materials, and automation. As a result, mastering the necessary techniques requires significant training and learning investment.
Rapid Development:
With the continuous advancement of technology, SMT is constantly evolving. Manufacturers need to stay updated on the latest technological developments and equipment to maintain competitiveness and production efficiency.
Advantages of Through-Hole Technology
Strong Mechanical Connection:
One of the primary advantages of THT is the strong mechanical bond it forms between components and the PCB. Component leads are inserted into drilled holes and soldered, creating a durable connection. This makes THT suitable for applications where PCBs face physical stress or harsh environments, such as aerospace, military, or automotive industries.
Ease of Prototyping and Manual Adjustments:
Larger components and leads are easier to handle, making THT ideal for prototyping or small-scale production. This is especially useful when frequent modifications are required, as components can be easily added, removed, or replaced.
High-Frequency Applications:
THT also offers better performance in high-frequency applications. The leads in THT components can act as short antennas, helping reduce the impact of Radio Frequency Interference (RFI). This makes THT a preferred choice for high-frequency or RF applications.
Better Heat Resistance:
THT components typically offer greater heat resistance than SMT components. Their larger size and the fact that they are not directly attached to the PCB surface make them more suitable for applications exposed to high temperatures, such as power electronics or industrial machinery.
Easier Testing and Inspection:
THT allows for easier inspection and testing of assembled PCBs. Visible connections make it simpler to identify and correct any defects in manual soldering or component placement, which can enhance product quality and reliability—critical in industries where failure is not an option.
Disadvantages of Through-Hole Technology
Larger Components (Limiting PCB Space Utilization):
Each component lead requires a drilled hole, which occupies significant PCB space. This not only limits the number of components that can be placed on the board but also restricts signal routing, potentially affecting overall circuit performance. The larger size of THT components further contributes to this inefficiency. As electronic devices become smaller, the demand for smaller components and more compact PCBs grows, and THT often falls short compared to newer technologies like SMT, which allows smaller components to be placed on both sides of the PCB.
Labor-Intensive and Slower Assembly Process:
Another drawback of THT is the increased complexity and time consumption in the assembly process. The need to drill holes, insert leads, and solder them makes THT more labor-intensive and slower than SMT. This can lead to higher production costs, especially for large-scale manufacturing.
Longer Leads and Pathways:
THT is also less efficient for high-speed or high-frequency applications. The longer leads and pathways increase inductance and capacitance, leading to signal distortion in high-frequency signals. This makes THT less suitable for applications like high-speed computing or telecommunications, where signal integrity is crucial.
Environmental Impact:
The drilling process generates significant waste, and the use of lead-based solder poses environmental and health risks. While lead-free solder alternatives exist, they come with their own challenges, such as higher melting points and potential reliability issues.
Combining SMT and THT
Although SMT and THT are often seen as distinct or competing assembly methods, it’s important to note that they are not mutually exclusive. In fact, they are frequently used together in a single product to leverage the advantages of both technologies.
It’s not uncommon to find both THT and SMT components in many electronic assemblies. The decision on which to use is typically driven by the specific application’s requirements, component availability, and the characteristics and constraints of the assembly process.
For instance, a memory board might be configured with Dual Inline Package (DIP) memory devices using THT on the top and SMT capacitors on the bottom. In such a hybrid setup, the unnecessary electrical noise is reduced compared to using THT in all cases. This noise reduction results in fewer decoupling capacitors being needed for effective decoupling.
Conclusion
Both Through-Hole Technology and Surface Mount Technology have unique advantages and disadvantages. The choice between the two is not about one being better than the other, but about the specific requirements of the application. SMT enhances automation and component density by soldering small electronic components directly onto pads on the surface of the PCB. THT, on the other hand, involves inserting leaded components into drilled holes on the PCB and soldering them, making it suitable for components that require higher current-carrying capacity or special packaging forms.
As a result, PCB assembly often combines the precision of SMT with the stability and reliability of THT, aiming to achieve efficient and dependable production of electronic products while meeting diverse performance and cost requirements. This hybrid approach provides greater flexibility in PCB design, catering to a wide range of needs from small portable devices to large industrial control systems.
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
:sales@leadsintec.com
